Hunger Games: Dawn on the Reaping, Panem and reheated soup

The return to Panem with Haymitch as the protagonist does not refresh a tired formula

di Claudio Pofi
Segui Gamesurf su Google

There is a limit beyond which telling the past of a beloved character risks becoming an exercise in nostalgia for its own sake. This is the feeling that accompanies much of the viewing of Hunger Games: Dawn on the Reaping, a prequel dedicated to Haymitch Abernathy, the future mentor of Katniss Everdeen and Peeta Mellark.

The first hour is almost as suffocating as a political talk show. The preparation for the fiftieth edition of the Hunger Games drags on without managing to justify such a prolonged runtime. The narrative struggles to find a rhythm and interest progressively slips, making way for a long wait for the entry into the arena. Only when the confrontation between the tributes approaches, the film might shake off the initial torpor, regaining some of the lost attention. A recovery that, however, is not enough to erase a decidedly too verbose beginning.

Haymitch, instructions for a déjà-vu

The entry into the arena should represent the moment when the film shifts gears. In reality, even here, surprises are few. The clashes follow already widely known dynamics, with situations that re-propose a narrative scheme that is now worn out. The packaging is the same as always, but something is missing that truly justifies the return to Panem.

Francis Lawrence knows the material well and knows how to craft a visually effective spectacle, but this time the direction is not enough to hide the limitations of a story that seems to exist primarily to fill some gaps in the saga. Even the protagonist fails to make the mark as he should: the future Haymitch, played by Joseph Zada, comes across as sui generis, finding him in the final scenes in a rather foolish way. The original language dialogues don't help either: originally from Australia, Zada has a speech that sounds like it came from a working-class London neighborhood, with Cockney inflections and a rather questionable vocal characterization.

Making the feeling of an inessential operation even more evident is the aforementioned final fan service, which tries to tie every element back to Katniss's story. A connection designed to satisfy fans, but which ultimately confirms the film's main limitation: telling something the audience already knows, without adding enough to make it truly necessary.

Hunger Games: Dawn on the Reaping remains a technically solid product, but fails to find its own narrative purpose. Did the saga still have something to tell, or was it just the desire to return to Panem that guided this commercial operation? After watching it, the second hypothesis seems decidedly more convincing.