World of Warcraft Forever Review: Blizzard Rewrites the Future of Old Azeroth
Blizzard returns to the roots of its MMORPG with new quests, revamped classes, and progression that values the journey.
Blizzard has decided to play dirty with our memories. To introduce World of Warcraft: Forever, it returned to that 2004 cinematic that many fans practically know by heart, even bringing back the famous dwarf hunter accompanied by his inseparable bear. A perfectly orchestrated nostalgia operation, it must be admitted, especially for those who experienced the early days of an MMORPG capable of transforming evenings in front of the computer into endless expeditions across Azeroth. Those were the years when reaching level 60 was an achievement, obtaining your first mount required significant economic sacrifices, and traversing an unknown region could cost us a long walk from the nearest graveyard. Good times, at least until you had to retrieve your corpse for the fifth time.
The new cinematic revisits that imagery but also introduces an interesting change. Our old hunter no longer seems to worry only about the battles that await him, preferring to venture into unexplored territories. A choice that quite well illustrates Blizzard's intentions: to return to the original Azeroth to discover what we never had the opportunity to visit, without necessarily having to invent yet another cosmic threat ready to endanger the entire universe. And if you think about it, this is precisely one of the aspects that made the first World of Warcraft unforgettable. We didn't know what awaited us beyond a mountain, what creature we would encounter in the next forest, or what rewards a newly discovered expedition hid.
The problem is that twenty-two years have passed, and in the meantime, Azeroth has lost most of its secrets. Between expansions, guides, databases, and strategies perfected by the community, even the return to origins proposed by World of Warcraft Classic in 2019 ended up transforming into a race along paths we already knew all too well. The nostalgia effect certainly worked, but how long could the charm of an adventure whose every detail we knew practically last?
With World of Warcraft: Forever, Blizzard therefore tries to do something many players have been asking for: resume the development of the original MMORPG as if its story had taken a different path, maintaining the level 60 cap and enriching the old continents with new regions, quests, dungeons, and progression possibilities. An idea that on paper has all the potential to win over veterans, but which must contend with a rather important question: how much of the old formula can still work today, especially after over twenty years of genre evolution? Because seeing that dwarf and his bear again was certainly exciting, but to convince us to spend hundreds more hours in Azeroth, something more than a nice cinematic is needed.
Azeroth Changes, But Don't Touch Its Foundations!
Those who played the first World of Warcraft will probably remember how challenging it was to reach level 60. Not only because of the amount of experience required, but especially because the game seemed to enjoy complicating our lives in every possible way. Quests scattered across distant regions, creatures capable of eliminating us with a few blows, and an economic availability that, at least initially, didn't even allow us to purchase all available abilities. Not to mention those moments when, after completing the tasks in a certain area, we found ourselves wandering through Azeroth looking for someone willing to give us another job. Well, Forever recovers much of this philosophy, but also tries to correct some of its most obvious rigidities, without transforming the experience into what the modern World of Warcraft offers.
The main novelty concerns the introduction of over a thousand additional quests, distributed along the entire character growth path, accompanied by new regions such as Mount Hyjal, Shen'dralas, and Riverglades. The latter, designed especially for intermediate levels, offers over one hundred and fifty tasks, while Hyjal finally allows exploration of one of the most important places in Warcraft history, long out of reach for players. Blizzard, however, has not forgotten the zones we now know by heart, also intervening on the original settings with new characters, rewards, and situations that seem to belong to the game since 2004. Think of the first quests around Northshire, where some new elite adversaries transform the usual incursions into the kobold mines into something decidedly less peaceful. If once it was enough to worry about retrieving some candles (without even asking why those creatures were so jealous of them), today it might be necessary to find someone willing to help us before ending up badly in the graveyard.
This greater quantity of content also allows for progression with a certain continuity, avoiding some of the annoying gaps that characterized Vanilla. Level 10, for example, can be reached in a few hours instead of requiring entire days, while the higher number of tasks reduces the need to constantly traverse different regions in search of experience. Be careful, however, because it doesn't mean that Forever has suddenly embraced the philosophy of the modern game. Progression remains deliberately slow, and every equipment improvement continues to have a concrete weight, especially when it finally allows us to face creatures that, until a few levels prior, represented a considerable threat. Rather, the risk seems to be the opposite: between additional quests, better rewards, and enhancements obtained from professions, it can happen to reach some zones with an excessive advantage, diminishing part of the original difficulty. A compromise probably necessary to attract new players, but which might leave some veterans, more attached to Vanilla's severity, with some perplexity.
The class system has also received similar treatment, with modifications designed primarily to make specializations usable that encountered significant difficulties in the original game. Do you remember the Protection Warrior? On paper, it represented the classic armored fighter, capable of absorbing blows and protecting the group, but during progression, it suffered greatly in Rage generation, making it generally more convenient to choose Arms and rely on a good two-handed weapon. Forever introduces talents like Shield Specialization and Master of Defense, which allow Rage generation through blocks and, with a shield equipped, also parries and dodges. A change that finally offers a concrete reason to develop a tank from the early levels. The Shaman, on the other hand, can use Enhancement and their totems to temporarily sustain the defensive role in less demanding dungeons, without becoming a true tank specialization. The Druid also benefits from greater attention, with Feral and Balance finally more competitive than in the past.
Even more interesting is the Paladin, a class that in Vanilla seemed destined to spend most of its career healing others, regardless of the player's initial intentions. Blizzard has improved both Protection and Retribution, introducing more effective tools to generate threat and make offensive combat less monotonous. The arrival of Holy Strike, along with the ability to use Judgement without consuming the active Seal, helps make the first few hours more dynamic, without completely overturning the class's original functionality. To all this are added new combinations of races and classes, such as the Dwarf Shaman and the Forsaken Paladin, which further expand customization possibilities.
Fortunately, Blizzard has also preserved one of the most interesting features of the old progression system: class-specific quests, those that transformed learning an ability into a small adventure. A Shaman, for example, still has to traverse entire regions to obtain their Water Totems, while Warriors can once again pursue the famous Whirlwind Axe, a reward many veterans will remember with particular fondness. These are tasks that require time, travel, and sometimes the help of other players, but which contribute to making the character something more than a simple collection of statistics.
Overall, the class revision seems to have taken a convincing direction, even if the balance interventions published during the first week demonstrate that the work is far from over. Forever's true achievement is not making everyone more powerful, but restoring dignity to specializations that were often ignored. And if this means being able to face an entire career as a Protection Paladin without being frowned upon by the rest of the group, we'd say some progress has been made.
Between a Campfire and a Dungeon, Azeroth Returns to Grouping Up
If there's one thing the first World of Warcraft did particularly well, it was convincing us that even seemingly secondary activities had their importance. Gathering minerals, brewing some potions, or learning to cook wasn't just a pastime for those who had run out of available quests, but could turn into a concrete advantage during the adventure. And anyone who spent a few hours gathering materials to craft a new piece of equipment will probably remember how satisfying it was to wear it, especially when it finally allowed them to face that enemy who, just minutes before, had repeatedly sent them to the graveyard. Forever recovers this philosophy and seeks to further enhance it, anticipating access to professions already in the early areas and introducing new recipes capable of accompanying character growth.
The change may seem marginal, but it significantly alters players' habits. You no longer have to wait to reach a capital to learn how to mine, gather herbs, or skin animals, thus avoiding leaving behind a considerable amount of resources. Production professions have also received new recipes, some of which require materials from different activities. A blacksmith, for example, might need components obtained through Enchanting to craft equipment usable around level ten. A choice that encourages trade, especially since the new crafting system allows obtaining items sometimes superior to quest rewards. However, there are also consequences for balance, as a character particularly attentive to professions can find themselves much better equipped than expected by traditional progression, further reducing the difficulty of some zones.
Cooking and First Aid have also gained importance, thanks to the ability to prepare foods that can improve stats and, in some cases, provide small experience bonuses. First Aid also allows for the creation of early healing potions using materials like herbs, while still leaving Alchemy the task of producing more advanced ones. These are interesting changes because they restore utility to systems that over time had come to be considered almost exclusively in terms of endgame.
But the most enjoyable novelty, and probably one of the most successful of the entire project, concerns the Camping System, a system that allows players to set up small camps around campfires. Those with certain professions can contribute by adding items capable of providing buffs, up to a maximum of three different benefits in basic campfires, a number that can rise to five or ten using advanced ones. Just stopping for about a minute is enough to obtain them, thus taking advantage of benefits that can significantly improve character performance. Some are quite specific, like the whetstones made by blacksmiths to increase Strength, while others offer general stat increases. However, attention must be paid to overlaps with class abilities, as not all buffs can be freely stacked. A Paladin, for example, will have little interest in obtaining a benefit equivalent to one of their own Blessings, preferring something normally available through Shaman Totems.
The beauty, however, is that these camps primarily function as small gathering points, bringing back to the center of the experience an aspect that has progressively been lost over the years. Stopping by a campfire means meeting other adventurers, perhaps exchanging a few words, or finding someone willing to tackle a particularly challenging quest. You don't necessarily need extensive social functionality to encourage players to interact with each other; sometimes, just giving them a reason to stop in the same place is enough. It's a shame, though, that the system doesn't always clearly communicate how much time remains before a camp disappears, with the risk of sitting by the fire and seeing it extinguish just as we were about to get the benefits. A minor inconvenience that Blizzard could solve by introducing a remaining duration indicator, or by allowing the campfire to be refueled.
And what better occasion to test all this equipment, perhaps with newly made friends, than one of the available dungeons? Forever introduces nine of them, distributed throughout progression and set in places that fans of the Warcraft universe know quite well. Think of the Ruins of Lordaeron, which allow exploration of what remains of the ancient human capital, traversing environments populated by undead and recovering documents related to the victims of its fall. Some can even be returned to surviving relatives, a particularly welcome narrative detail because it allows for a deeper understanding of the place's history without necessarily relying on long cinematics. The Hall of Thanes, on the other hand, recaptures the charm of great underground fortresses, offering a journey that might remind Tolkien fans of the Mines of Moria.
The philosophy remains that of the original dungeons. Bosses don't require memorizing dozens of different mechanics, but they can still challenge an unorganized group. Attracting too many enemies simultaneously, forgetting to interrupt a dangerous ability, or underestimating the importance of crowd control can turn a seemingly simple encounter into a collective defeat. Preparation also retains some importance, especially since many dungeon-specific quests must be picked up in the surrounding regions, encouraging the group to explore before entering the instance. The result is an experience that rewards collaboration without necessarily requiring hours of organization, considering that some of the new dungeons can be completed in about twenty minutes by a sufficiently experienced group.
Blizzard, however, has introduced a controversial change, significantly reducing the experience gained by eliminating enemies within dungeons. The goal is to prevent continuous repetition of the same instances from becoming the most convenient method to reach level 60, instead pushing players to complete available quests in the open world. After initial protests, the company intervened by increasing the experience gained from kills from 40% to 60% of the values expected in Classic Era, without fully restoring the original system. This change therefore affects enemies eliminated in dungeons, not the overall rewards obtained by completing tasks.
The intention is understandable, especially considering how much Blizzard wants to emphasize the sense of discovery, limiting the ability to know all the rewards and mechanics of new dungeons in advance. The absence of a journal detailing every boss, along with measures taken against the premature spread of information, could finally restore that feeling of uncertainty that characterized the first World of Warcraft raids. Because let's admit it, entering a dungeon already knowing the equipment to retrieve, the strategy to use, and even the exact moment to move takes away much of the fun. And if Forever truly manages to make us stand before a boss again, wondering how on earth it's possible to defeat it, without immediately having a guide ready to solve the problem, it will have recovered something much more important than some old mechanics.
Another Character? This Time It's Not Wasted Time!
Anyone who has spent enough time in World of Warcraft will probably be familiar with that particular form of indecision that manifests itself in front of the character selection screen. We've finally reached a good level with our Warrior, perhaps even acquiring some interesting pieces of equipment, but suddenly we feel like trying a Mage. Or a Druid. Or maybe that Shaman we had always ignored because someone, twenty years ago, convinced us it wasn't particularly effective. The problem is that starting over meant temporarily abandoning all progress made, dedicating dozens more hours to an adventure we already knew all too well. Forever tries to change this perspective through the Legacy System, one of the most interesting innovations introduced by Blizzard, especially for those who consider creating secondary characters a fundamental part of the experience.
The operation is quite simple. By completing certain challenges related to classes, professions, exploration, dungeons, and PvP, the player earns Legacy Points, shared among non-Hardcore characters on their Battle.net account. At launch, sixty-five challenges are available, while each character can invest up to sixteen points in different progression branches, gaining benefits related to their activities. The system also allows unlocking cosmetic rewards, without necessarily forcing players to develop multiple characters to complete the path. Those who prefer to focus on their main character can continue to do so, while fans of secondary characters finally find an additional reason to experiment with new classes and professions.
What makes the Legacy System interesting is primarily the ability to separate, at least in part, account progression from individual character progression. A Paladin engaged in dungeons can contribute to the same goals as a Mage dedicated to professions, allowing the player to choose what to do without constantly feeling like they are neglecting their main hero. This philosophy is reminiscent of some solutions already adopted by MMORPGs like Guild Wars 2, where shared progress encourages experimentation without turning every new character into a completely independent investment. Naturally, the quality of the system will also depend on the content Blizzard adds in the coming months, especially since the number of usable points is currently limited and some challenges involve high-level activities not yet available. Nevertheless, it remains a convincing addition, capable of enhancing the entire journey rather than exclusively rewarding those who reach the maximum level first.
But to allow all these adventurers to share the same Azeroth, Blizzard also had to revise the server infrastructure. Forever abandons the traditional realm selection, introducing large communities organized according to different game modes, including Normal, PvP, Role-Playing, and PvP Role-Playing. In essence, you no longer have to worry about choosing the right server hoping it won't empty out after a few months. Simply select your preferred mode to enter an ecosystem shared with other players who have made the same choice. A particularly convenient solution, especially for those new to World of Warcraft who have no intention of studying the population of dozens of realms before even creating their character.
The initiative seems to have been well-received by the community, also considering the turnout recorded during the first few days. Blizzard stated that Forever achieved the highest peak of concurrent players ever reached during a World of Warcraft launch, accompanied by a particularly high number of returning users. A significant result, although lacking sufficiently detailed public data to independently verify its scope. On the technical front, moreover, the server launch seems to have been relatively smooth, with contained queues and rather limited initial problems. All good, then? Not exactly, because the real problem emerged once in the game world, mainly due to the system used to distribute the population across different zones.
We are talking about the so-called layering, a technology that allows creating parallel copies of open-world zones to prevent thousands of characters from contending for the same kobold. A certainly useful solution, at least until it decides to show some unconvincing behavior. Testimonies collected during the first week describe situations where crossing the border between two regions causes the sudden disappearance of surrounding players, replaced by others belonging to a different layer. In some cases, even the weather changes, going from a thunderstorm to a perfectly sunny day within a few steps. A nice surprise for those who wanted to rediscover the atmosphere of old Azeroth, especially since we hardly remember a continent where simply crossing a road was enough to change dimensions.
The problem becomes more serious when these changes interfere with combat. In PvP modes, it can happen that an opponent simply disappears by crossing a region's border, interrupting a fight without anyone having used particular abilities. Similar situations have also been reported during exploration, with creatures and players not always being correctly synchronized. Added to this is a not yet convincing population distribution, capable of alternating overcrowded zones, where completing a quest becomes a struggle against other players, with strangely deserted areas. Blizzard has already intervened to correct some of these behaviors, but the system still needs a lot of attention. After all, if the goal is to convince us that Azeroth is a living and shared world, seeing its inhabitants continuously materialize and disappear is not exactly the best way to achieve it.
A similar discussion concerns faction balance in PvP modes. To prevent the Alliance and Horde from reaching excessively high numerical differences, Blizzard has introduced temporary restrictions on the creation of new characters in the dominant faction. The decision is understandable, because constantly facing numerically superior groups of opponents can turn exploring contested regions into a rather frustrating experience. The problem is that this system also risks preventing a new player from joining their friends, perhaps after purchasing a subscription specifically to play with them. A far from ideal situation for an MMORPG that has made socialization one of its fundamental principles. Maintaining a balanced conflict between factions is important, but preventing friends from sharing the adventure is a difficult compromise to accept, especially when faction choice constitutes such an important part of a character's identity.
A Return That Still Needs to Prove Its Longevity
At this point, World of Warcraft: Forever seems to have found a rather convincing direction, especially because it doesn't merely rehash the past by relying exclusively on nostalgia. The new quests naturally fit into the original world, the class overhaul restores importance to specializations that had been marginalized for years, and the revamped professions once again encourage players to collaborate. Added to all this are the Camping System, the Legacy System, and a visual compartment capable of enhancing Azeroth without erasing its identity. These are interventions that seem to understand quite well what made the old MMORPG special, while recognizing that some of its rigidities didn't necessarily deserve to be preserved.
Problems remain to be addressed in server management, faction balance, and some progression choices. Most importantly, a fundamental part of Forever has yet to show its hand. The first raids, scheduled for December 9th, will allow for a better evaluation of the endgame, while subsequent updates will have to demonstrate whether the Legacy System and horizontal progression can keep interest alive even after level 60. Considering the nature of an MMORPG destined to evolve over time, pronouncing on the longevity of the experience today would be at least premature.
For now, Blizzard seems to have found a convincing way to return to its origins without turning Azeroth into a museum dedicated to veterans. Content remains to be discovered and problems to be corrected, but the charm of World of Warcraft didn't just depend on the places we visited, but on everything that could happen to us while we tried to reach them. Forever is trying to recapture precisely that feeling. It remains to be seen if it can preserve it when even Azeroth's new roads become familiar.