GTA VI Review: Rockstar Survives Expectations

Unprecedented animations, a living Leonida that thrives even without us, and new weight for every choice: GTA 6 survives expectations and aims for the role once held by GTA III. A few imperfections and 30 FPS don't diminish its impact.

di Claudio Magistrelli
Segui Gamesurf su Google

The most anticipated game ever: there's no point in beating around the bush, GTA VI will hit the global entertainment industry tomorrow like a meteorite. In recent months, years, and days, news surrounding Rockstar's new open world has chased each other, often moving through that thin membrane separating reality from fiction, from cyberattacks to steal info about the game to gags about November 19th in the latest season of South Park, from memes about what we had before GTA VI to records of vacation days requested worldwide to play the event of the year (decade?) on day one. In short, in the history of introductory paragraphs, it's hard to recall a title that needs fewer introductions. So let's cut to the chase and get straight to the point. 

The Story of GTA VI: Jason and Lucia, an Unintentional Criminal Ascent

By now, GTA VI's two protagonists have been part of the collective imagination for so long that it almost feels like we already know them. Instead, surprises concerning them (which, of course, will not be revealed here) abound from the very first moments. He's a former soldier, a good-looking guy, handsome, square jaw, broad shoulders, tough gaze. She's Latina, a mix of distrust and sweetness in her features, and a rather eventful recent past, which is why in one of the very first assignments, it's up to Jason to offer her a ride right after she walks out of prison. 

The stroke of luck in the form of a government program that allows Lucia to leave prison early is accompanied by an electronic ankle bracelet and a lot of good intentions: start over, settle down, and leave the life of expedients behind. A future together initially appears to be a strong enough goal to keep Jason & Lucia on the straight and narrow, just long enough to discover they're not welcome: any kind of project requires money, a resource no bank is willing to lend to people like them. Apparently, with a past like theirs, they can't even afford a real bank account. 

The first clash with GTA's typical mocking critique of contemporaneity (this time more bitter and, more than ever, on the border between realism and fiction) quickly leads the couple to seek new ways to make money from old acquaintances. In Lucia's case, these are mostly former cellmates, while for Jason, they are the faces of Brian's small gang, composed of the aforementioned plus Donnie and Cal, mostly dedicated to illicit but rather varied dealings. 

Jason & Lucia's criminal ascent in GTA VI is almost involuntary. The underlying goal remains to leave this life behind to build a new one, but not before saving enough capital to start everything from scratch elsewhere, where no one knows (or recognizes) you. But to make big money, you need to know increasingly powerful people. And Jason & Lucia desperately need to find someone they can trust, because without knowing it, they've gotten themselves into a big mess that they can't get out of alone. 

I've completely avoided spoilers, so as not to ruin the surprise for anyone, but even without going into too much detail, the relationship between the two protagonists mirrors one of the game's main themes: the consequences of one's decisions. The game's events vary depending on the player's actions at certain key junctures, but more generally, Jason & Lucia's daily behavior has an impact on their future. However, it's time to discuss this after introducing other game elements and, above all, a fundamental concept: the naturalness with which Leonida winks at reality. 

GTA 6 Graphics and Animations: The Biggest Technical Leap in Years

One of the first things you realize upon first contact with GTA VI is that everything we saw in the trailers in recent months was true: that lighting, that level of detail, that atmosphere all hit you at once on first launch. The impact is one you feel. Just the very first seconds in control of Lucia are enough to find yourself open-mouthed in front of a window, as the sunset light rays outside filter through the blinds and spread undulating over the bodies that cross them, while in backlight, dust stirs in the air. And how those bodies move. 

GTA VI's animations are undoubtedly  the most incredible ever seen in a video game, both for their verisimilitude and fluidity. Forget the breaks between one action and another: they're gone (almost, we'll talk about this later) entirely. Jason and Lucia move around the house like cats, open the fridge, sit down  stand up, eat a sandwich with one hand and drink a soda with the other. The quality of modeling and textures is astounding, to the point that bodies show stretch marks while direct light highlights muscles or subcutaneous fat with shadows. Overall, GTA VI represents a technical leap forward unlike any seen in the sector for quite some time, but it wouldn't have the same impact if it weren't accompanied by something else. 

Naturalness is the word that probably best summarizes the overall experience with GTA VI: the naturalness in the movements of all characters in every situation, the naturalness with which multiple light sources interact with moving objects and bodies, the naturalness with which clouds gather, in short, the naturalness with which the world of Leonida continues around Jason & Lucia regardless of Jason & Lucia. 

In the same way, there is no more appropriate word than naturalness to describe Leonida's weather and how it influences the game's look through lighting: I perceived the first storm approaching by the way the light changed around the character, even before I spotted the dark clouds on the horizon. Across the vast landscapes of the region, ranging from swamps to exclusive oceanfront villas, from the Keys to the neon of Vice City's skyscrapers, weather conditions are constantly evolving; wind and leaden clouds anticipate the arrival of storms, while in the swamps at night, a deadly fog can rise. Fortunately, there's an app on your phone that lets you keep an eye on the forecast and plan if you want to venture into nature, perhaps in search of some rare species. Nothing, however, can prepare you for the darkness of night in GTA VI, cut only by a car's headlights. 

On top of all this, a disarming amount of detail often rains down: the most trivial example is the vastness of the horizon, the thousands of light sources observed in flight at night, and the possibility of descending towards each one, but even at the micro level, details are not lacking; in fact, perhaps they impress even more. Although the quantity of objects with which one can interact is actually limited, nothing appears fake, nothing is immovably anchored to the scenery, everything seems to have its own mass and consequently respond to physical laws. 

Leonida, Between Realism and Verisimilitude: Game Systems, Police, and Daily Life

One of the strangest effects of the verisimilitude of everything seen on screen is that the actions performed by our character carry a different weight than in the past. Despite the everyday nature of some of the actions required to maintain health, physical condition, and partner relationship, such as eating, exercising, or holding hands on the way to rob a bank, the naturalness of the micro and macro context in which the characters move almost unconsciously leads to ordinary actions like heading to the fridge when leaving the room upon waking or promising to actually do two sets of squats tomorrow morning. 

In this sense, GTA VI achieves a great balancing act, moving precisely on a membrane between realism and verisimilitude, drawing a line before overcomplicating things. Several common operations are more elaborate than usual. It's no longer enough to press a button to steal a car; depending on the model, mechanical or electronic tools are needed, which are acquired during the game. More operations to perform (often with QTEs or mini-games to solve), more time required, more risks. But fortunately, without excessive complexity in button combinations. And if you're thinking of smashing a window, know that police behavior in Leonida is also much more sophisticated, with search areas linked to appearance and reported vehicle, in addition to the usual star system. Compared to the past, everything is more sophisticated, but not necessarily complicated. For example, lack of training will affect Jason & Lucia's athletic abilities but without radical consequences, while still benefiting (simply, in brawls) from dedication. 

As a result of the sum of these factors, the game itself pushes the player to replicate and fuel its realism: in this sense, it can be said that there is certainly a role-playing component in GTA VI. Since the world reacts plausibly, it becomes instinctive to treat it plausibly, even finding oneself almost unconsciously performing small daily gestures, adopting more careful driving (or looking at one's phone while driving, depending on your habits), avoiding leaving unnecessary victims on the ground. And all just because graphics and game systems manage to convey the consequences of the player's actions more effectively. 

Heists, Fences, and Money: How Jason and Lucia's Other Life Works

As mentioned earlier, the weight of decisions is felt in every aspect of GTA VI, and this is also reflected in Jason & Lucia's other life, namely their criminal one, both for direct and indirect consequences. Clean hits mean no one gets hurt and the police arrive more calmly, while a more aggressive approach leads to reckless reactions from those present and widespread searches. Although it's difficult not to get your hands dirty in Vice City, the presence or absence of scruples in every context will influence the couple's criminal perception and the attitude of the figures revolving around them, conditioning their destinies (as well as the story's ending). 

Whether you're gentle thieves or ruthless raiders, Leonida offers you a wide range of opportunities. Essentially, every commercial activity is robbable. But is it worth the trouble for a few pennies? Better to focus on banks, small or large with different security levels, or jewelry stores with their fat safes. Or why not uproot an ATM? For those who can keep their cool, Leonida offers a sea of opportunities, reserved however for the few capable of disarming guards, getting combinations, quickly recovering the loot, and disappearing before the sirens arrive. If you prefer cars, a couple of your contacts can give you a list of desired models, also indicating where the unfortunate owners park them. More generally, whatever you manage to get your hands on, know that you'll find a fence ready to buy it from you. Between Vice City and Leonida, someone who can appreciate those gold doubloons you recovered from an ancient wreck while diving off the Keys is sure to be found. 

The problem is often getting to the fence. The loot is stored in bags, to be carried around or kept in the car trunk, perhaps along with some clothes to change into and arouse less suspicion. It's quite obvious that if we get caught, that stuff disappears; so after a heist, it's better to keep a low profile. Then comes the problem of managing money between cash, bank account (when you can afford it), the BuckMe app, and especially the savings fund for the future: how many heists does it take to guarantee a future of anonymous happiness? 

The Realism of GTA VI: Choices, Consequences, and the Couple at the Heart of the Game

GTA VI strikes in a significantly different way compared to previous chapters. Throughout the entire test, I tried to decide whether the game's tone, drier and more mature even if not without the saga's classic exaggerations, depended on GTA's attempt to adhere more closely to reality or on the fact that since the previous chapter, reality itself had transformed into GTA. Discussing it with Rob Nelson, the game's head of development, during a feedback session organized by Rockstar's PR during the review phase, it emerged that the studio is aware of the effect due to the verisimilitude of this new chapter and has worked precisely in this direction, trying to exploit its emotional potential, while in the background of our daily lives, the exaggerations that GTA satirized have ended up being absorbed and normalized. Perhaps this GTA VI marks the meeting point between the saga and reality: Cal (in my opinion, one of the game's best characters) makes strange speeches, but not so different from those of your neighbor or colleague. 

Even if the mere graphical and technological leap would be enough to stand up in front of Rockstar's work, all this wonder of animations and dynamic lights is put at the service of a game design idea: to place the player in a world where they are free to do anything, but without removing the consequences from the table. Not that you can't slaughter anything that moves in the frame, but you have to deal with a little more emotional investment than what polygons and textures have accustomed us to so far. GTA VI is a game that talks about choices and consequences not only through the story but through the actions it allows the player to take. 

Let's go back to Jason & Lucia: they are not two protagonists, but a couple. And that makes a big difference. Their destiny is linked; one's choices influence the other. Although there are also missions that can only be tackled by one of the two, dividing them is a more forced choice than in the past, and it ends up being used differently for this reason. For example, switching to the passenger's role during a long journey is a way to let the AI handle the driving (perhaps during one of the frequent highway stretches) while enjoying the scenery, looking at something on your phone, or deepening the relationship between the two by having them converse. An almost meditative experience. 

And in a context that, also thanks to technical merits, manages to expand stronger roots, every action carries a stronger weight. More adrenaline-pumping heists. Car chases accompanied by action-movie-like pursuits and rollovers. Missions also adapt, and stripped of long, empty drives spent chatting in the car, they are much more often an opportunity to showcase spectacular set pieces and gradually raise the stakes. GTA VI, at its root, is the GTA we know, but the execution is of such a high level that it changes the way it is played, perceived, and almost lived. 

There Will Be a Before and After GTA VI 

Surviving expectations would have already been a success for GTA VI, but Rockstar has managed to go beyond. It's not simply the hyper-detailed graphics or the fluid and realistic animations that take center stage, but the sum of the whole that is astonishing. To use recent comparisons, GTA VI expands to an boundless game world what IO Interactive did on a smaller scale with 007 First Light: if the nightclub scene remained etched in the minds of all who played the latest Bondian adventure, in Leonida there are at least a dozen nights and strip clubs. Or, to stick with comparisons, GTA VI embraces the grandeur and arrogance of Crimson Desert, but rationalizes its structure, blends its systems, and, by foregoing the superfluous, delivers a cohesive, consistent experience, without a single misplaced comma. A masterfully directed work, in the sense we usually use when there's a great director behind it (and the first one that comes to mind for obvious iconographic references is Michael Mann). 

Said like that, it seems GTA VI has no flaws, but that's not true, and some have already been mentioned in the preceding lines. We can add the 30 FPS, some textures that define a bit too suddenly now and then, sporadic occasions where the fluidity of animations stutters, or the rare times something gets stuck. There are some imperfections here and there, but on one hand, it's unthinkable not to find them in a frankly boundless game world where details and minutiae  far exceed the occasional flaws. On the other hand, when these small imperfections occur, they are felt more, precisely because they break the illusion that such a plausible and coherent context erects. But overall, they remain truly negligible compared to everything GTA VI does at a level that is simply the state of the art from every point of view you want to look at it. 

It's always a gamble to talk about the future, but GTA VI could be the chapter in the saga that will come closest to GTA III in terms of industry impact. Just as Rockstar's Liberty City at the time shed new light on the concept of three-dimensional freedom, GTA VI could have opened up the horizon of what can be done in a video game, forcing everyone to chase a bar set incredibly high. From generation to generation, the myth of the game that looks like a movie has been pursued: GTA VI is the closest we have ever come to this goal. Rockstar's talent lies in not simply making its talent a showcase, but in putting it at the service of narrative and emotions, crafting a memorable adventure. In short, they put their heart into it, in addition to the technique.