Echograph, previewed: Project Zero's legacy meets isometric pixel art

We tested the preview build of Pappy's Pipe Dream's survival horror for about forty-five minutes, featuring free exploration and first-person exorcisms.

di Alessandra Borgonovo
Segui Gamesurf su Google

When Project Zero burst onto the survival horror scene over twenty years ago, its most brilliant insight lay not only in the oppressive atmosphere of Japanese folklore, but also in the radical reversal of the genre's engagement rules. Depriving the player of firearms and blades to put a simple camera in their hands meant forcing them to look horror straight in the eyes, abandoning the instinct to flee to frame the threat just inches from the lens. It is precisely from this suggestion that Echograph, an intriguing independent project developed by Pappy's Pipe Dream for PC, takes its cue, and was the protagonist of a preview build that kept me busy for about forty-five minutes.

The narrative starting point delves deep into the genre's classic repertoire: we play as Layla, the sole survivor of a tragic night that wiped out her entire family. Years after the massacre, the woman decides to return to the dilapidated walls of her ancestral mansion to break the silence surrounding that slaughter, discover why she was the only one to survive, and confront a generational curse that still seems to haunt every room.

 

When the demo started, the first element to strike me was not, however, the reference to vintage gothic settings, but rather a precise choice of direction and spatial readability. Instead of slavishly replicating the fixed camera angles and clunky tank controls that defined the golden age of the nineties, Echograph adopts an isometric third-person view with a free camera during exploration. It's a solution that immediately gives great breadth to the action, allowing for natural reading of the environment's layout and unhindered movement, only to then break this safe distance with a sudden change of perspective: as soon as the camera is raised to confront the vengeful spirits, the view switches to first-person, bringing the tension back to a more "intimate" level.

Although the sources of inspiration are loudly declared - from the exploratory structure of the early Resident Evil and Alone in the Dark to the aforementioned photographic exorcism of Project Zero - defining Echograph as merely derivative would be unfair and misleading. While moving along well-recognizable coordinates, Pappy's Pipe Dream's work manages from these first stages to carve out its own convincing uniqueness, supported by refined retro pixel art and a build that, despite still lacking an official launch window, already appears surprisingly solid. The only small visual flaw concerns the animations of the specters, whose movements sometimes appear a bit mechanical and not very fluid; a detail that, however, in the context of an artistic direction anchored to the pixel aesthetic of the era, could even prove to be a precise stylistic choice rather than a real technical limitation.

Old-school survival grammar with a more modern touch

If isometric exploration grants the player the luxury of breathing and planning their movements, the first-person perspective imposed by using the camera immediately brings the experience back to the realm of pure thrill. Facing the preview build at Normal difficulty - an obligatory choice to test the balanced standard designed by the developers before venturing into more extreme challenges - it immediately becomes clear how Pappy's Pipe Dream has intelligently absorbed the lesson of Project Zero's Shutter Chance, but reinterpreting it with its own rules of engagement. The ghosts present in this initial portion do not yet shine for behavioral complexity, but the far-from-abundant supply of film rolls dictates that not a single shot should be wasted and that the chromatic scale of damage must be perfectly mastered.

When framing a presence in the viewfinder, the game communicates the potential effectiveness of the photograph through four distinct power levels, indicated by the color of the halo surrounding the crosshair: it starts from basic damage, obtained by framing the specter in the absence of any luminescence, to moderate damage characterized by an amber glow, up to the two most devastating thresholds, namely the red halo for high damage and the green one for maximum damage, capable not only of inflicting a critical hit but also of violently repelling the threat away from us. Achieving these last two reactions, however, requires a considerable amount of composure: one must read the timing of the enemy's movements and wait for the entity to approach an insignificant distance before pressing the shutter button. Missing the split second means exposing oneself to a lethal grab, from which it is fortunately possible to break free provided one has purifying salt with them, included as an emergency defensive item exactly as happened with Jill Valentine's daggers and tasers in the unforgettable Resident Evil Rebirth.

 

The real stroke of game design, however, lies in how Echograph manages the compromise between positioning and mobility. Unlike the historical chapters of Project Zero, where you could walk slowly with the camera raised but had to manually lower it before fleeing, here opening the lens completely pins Lyla in place, eliminating any possibility of lateral or backward movement. In return, the system allows you to immediately exit aiming mode by pressing the sprint button, instantly restoring third-person control. It's a surprisingly fresh and effective solution: it forces you to calculate angles, escape routes, and lines of fire with extreme clarity even before picking up the device, while also offering an immediate escape valve when the situation deteriorates. It remains to be seen if this grammar will be modified by the discovery of new lens upgrades - only one was present in the demo, designed to generate a group stun - but even as it is, the clashes can get spicy, especially when the specters start coordinating, attacking in pairs or launching projectiles from a distance in the form of small will-o'-the-wisp-like flames.

Chests, limited film rolls, and piano arguments

Supporting this constant tension is a resource management system rigorously anchored to the most uncompromising school of the nineties. Layla's inventory is limited, and every single item collected occupies a dedicated slot - including, a not insignificant detail, the camera upgrades themselves, forcing players to carefully evaluate what to carry and what to deposit in the classic chests kept in the save rooms.

Precisely on the resource economy front, a further brilliant divergence from the Project Zero model emerges. Firstly, Echograph eliminates any hierarchy between different types of film: there is no infinite supply of weak film rolls to fall back on in lean times, nor special films with devastating potential, but rather a single standard format. Since every shot has the same basic potential, the only way to make your ammunition count is to be daring and systematically aim for the red and green halos. Secondly, unlike Tecmo's masterpiece where photographing spectral clues or environmental seals did not deplete reserves, here every single click of the shutter actually consumes a film. When encountering a ghostly hand blocking access to a secondary object, as well as a fundamental door to proceed, the game presents the player with a tactical dilemma, especially in the first case: is it really worth sacrificing a precious shot to dissolve the obstacle and grab what it hides, or is it wiser to grit your teeth and move on?

 

On the puzzle front, the preview build proudly embraces all the cornerstones of survival horror tradition. Between ornamental keys to retrieve, missing statue fragments to reassemble, and safe combinations hidden in an entirely different wing of the building, genre veterans will immediately feel at home. A musical piano puzzle stood out for its challenge, requiring players to reproduce a precise melody while respecting extremely tight reaction windows, where even a single hesitation is enough to invalidate the entire attempt and force a restart.

Whispers beyond the frame

Narratively, Echograph chooses the path of silent stratification. After an introduction that clarifies the premises of Lyla's return to the family estate, the mansion's past and the roots of the curse are reconstructed through documents scattered throughout the rooms, personal notes, and the protagonist's own diary, which automatically updates at key points of the investigation. This paper trail is accompanied by actual spectral visions: Lyla's supernatural sensitivity already suggests that not all presences trapped within those walls are necessarily hostile or animated by malevolent intentions, hinting at interesting emotional nuances behind the family tragedy.

Finally, a skillfully crafted audio compartment helps to keep the guard constantly high. In a title that adopts a free isometric view, the risk is finding oneself with blind spots not immediately readable from the frame – yes, like in the '90s, but I'd say we've moved past that period; the developers circumvented the problem by transforming sound into a true sensory radar, capable of clearly signaling when a threat is lurking in the room still off-screen and allowing the player to react with appropriate anticipation. What do you say? The first Resident Evil already did that? Of course, and it's excellent that the game has maintained this logic, avoiding relying on its own free camera to deprive the player of no less vital sensory indications despite having total freedom in managing the framing.

 

At the end of these first forty-five minutes, Echograph leaves the impression of a project with very clear ideas, capable of honoring the golden age of survival horror without being trapped by it, refreshing its formula through a more expansive direction and a surprisingly tense photographic combat system. The only real unknown concerns the variety and complexity of the specters' attack patterns, which appeared rather linear in this introductory phase; an aspect that the full version will have ample space to enrich and layer, thus doing full justice to a story that has already managed to spark genuine curiosity about the curse that shattered Lyla's family.